Wednesday, May 13, 2026

Commander Toad and the Dis-asteroid

On May 9, something random from my childhood popped into my mind for no apparent reason: a story revolving around a misunderstanding of the phrase "beans swell" -- which was intended to mean that some beans had swollen to gigantic proportions but was understood to mean that beans are really "swell," in the dated slang sense of nifty or smashing. I searched the Internet in vain, finally resorted to consulting a Fake Intelligence, and found that the book I was thinking of was Commander Toad and the Dis-Asteroid by Janet Yolen, which I presumably read shortly after its 1985 publication.

The title's portmanteau of disaster and asteroid most naturally suggests the idea of an asteroid hitting Earth or something like that, but in fact the disaster takes place on an asteroid which is, despite its small size, an inhabited world. Responding to a cryptic SOS call ("Help. Help. Beans swell. Beans bad."), Commander Toad goes to this asteroid:

Ahead on the screen is a pleasant world. It is filled with water. There are no cities, no houses, no bus stops or barns. Just water everywhere. Above the water, calling softly as they fly, are thousands of doves.


They soon realize that this word is not as "pleasant" as it appears at first:

Mr. Hop thinks. "Everything is flooded," he says at last. "And that means that the pigeon folk who live here have nowhere to land."

Commander Toad looks out again. This time he understands. "I wonder how long they have been flying."

Doc Peeper looks out another peephole. "I will have to treat a lot of cases of tired wings," he says.

A dove flying over a flooded world is symbolism right out of Genesis -- both the Creation, where "the Spirit of God," later symbolized by the dove, "was hovering over the waters" of a world with no dry land (Gen. 1:2), and the Flood, where Noah sends a dove out of the ark but "the dove found no rest for the sole of her foot, and she returned unto him into the ark, for the waters were on the face of the whole earth" (Gen. 8:9).

In each case it is a single dove, though. For many birds flying over the flooded world and getting tired, we must turn to the Flood as portrayed in my Yes and No, quoted in "Ark in the dark" (December 2020).

The lions, tigers, bears, and horses
All were turned to bloated corses.
The cattle and the creeping things,
The fowl as well, whose worn-out wings
Had not at last the strength to keep
Them safe above the rising deep --
In short, all things in which was breath
Succumbed to universal death.
And God's own image, which had crowned
His whole creation, also drowned.

"Ark in the dark" coming up now is interesting, since I just posted "Voyage d'ark" yesterday.

In the story, it turns out the the asteroid is inhabited solely by intelligent doves, who has for some reason put let beans get in all their storm drains, where they swelled to enormous size, blocking the drains and causing the entire planet to flood. Stands to reason.

Last night I was listening to "Wild Roses" by Of Monsters and Men, and it occurred to me to wonder whether Nanna Bryndís Hilmarsdóttir had ever done any solo work. Wikipedia informed me that before OMAM she had performed as Songbird, and the most recent solo single mentioned in the article is "Disaster Master." Birds and disaster -- a  bit of a sync, though a rather weak one. I looked up the lyrics, which begin thus:

Take me out into the chaos
Waiting up for Helios
Bottled up with my emotions
Another drink to calm the ocean

The "chaos" and "ocean" references tie in with the doves over a flooded world, since in Genesis 1 this primeval ocean represents the chaos before Creation. Another line says:

Even Pluto was a planet, was a planet

Today Pluto is considered to be too small to count as a proper planet, though in the past it was classified as one. Asteroids, too, are too small to be planets, but in Commander Toad the asteroid is a "world."

Still relatively minor syncs, but I'm posting them anyway because it seems like they might develop into something.


Note added: In a comment, Bill points out that a flooded asteroid suggests Numenor, which was star-shaped (the literal meaning of the word asteroid). One of the illustrations in Commander Toad shows a "shooting star" that is actually star-shaped:


There's certainly a resemblance:


That particular way of anthropomorphizing a star foreshadows the SpongeBob character Patrick Star.

"Shooting" has come up before, for example in "Hello. Goodbye. Shoot this man" (July 2025 but recently linked in "Just-ice and Al-ice") and in Angelina's approving reference to Melville as a "straight shooter" in "Terry the Giant Irishman critiques my supposed literary preferences" (also July 2025).

Shooting stars feature in "All Star," a song which due to the Mandela Effect is now, it pains me to report, the signature song of what was in the old timeline a perfectly respectable ska-punk band. I posted about it in "All Star music video sync" (March 2025), a past that begins with a reference to "vulture bees." Vultures are the last birds mentioned in the closing paragraph of The Rot (see Laeth's comment below).


Second note added: I just checked todays Barnhardt Meme Barrage and found this:


Bill in the comments mentions Pluto being the god of wealth, but he's also the god of the Under world.

7 comments:

NLR said...

I enjoyed reading the commander Toad books when I was first starting to read. I went to the very end of the bookshelf, which must have been in alphabetical order, and was interesting in space at the time, so I picked them up.

Laeth said...

my novel The Rot ends with night coming after a long twilight during which the world was flooded, and the last paragraph is about flocks of birds flying over the waters.

William Wright (WW) said...

Symbolic of Numenor and its current flooded state - I think pretty clearly, starting with the word "asteroid" used to name the flooded world.

The word asteroid means "star-like" or literally "star shape or form". In Tolkien's writings, he described Numenor as being an island in the shape of a star. In that frame, it would be completely accurate to call Numenor an "asteroid".

Pluto is an interesting name to tie in here. It means "Wealth, God of Wealth", perhaps tying to the descriptions of Numenor having extreme wealth (and an increasing desire for it among the King's Men), with the Golden Man Pharazon considered in Tolkien's stories to be the wealthiest and most powerful man to have ever lived in any age of Middle-earth. Indeed, "Plutocracy" is a word used to describe the rule or power of the wealthy.

Pluto as a planet itself is an interesting symbol, given it is cold world covered in ice, similar to another symbol that came up in the form of Europa, Jupiter's moon. As you know, my own guess is that Numenor remains, to this day, under the flood in the form of water and ice that surround that world. Which poses a problem for us currently. Since Numenor is the Terrestrial Kingdom (in my thinking), and to leave this Telestial Kingdom, the Earth, we must be able to get to that world as laid out in the LDS temple drama, we are bound to this one until that situation is resolved. This gets to the symbolism of thousands of doves flying around with no place to land, getting tired wings.

I was thinking about the beans and how they tie in, and the best I could come up with is the story of Jack and the Beanstalk which very specifically came up in my own writing as symbolic of the Numenorean ascension to Aman. Jack (Nicholson) planted magic beans which enabled him to reach heaven, via the beanstalk, and I posed this as a garbled tale of Pharazon and the Numenoreans. It was their unauthorized voyage which caused the flood, and thus the loose tie to the "Dis-asteroid" in this other story of also being covered with water as a result of beans.

Wm Jas Tychonievich said...

I went to the last page of my digital copy of The Rot to reread the paragraph about the birds, but the last page is actually the author bio: "Laeth was born in nineteen eighty nine . . . he enjoys gardening."

When I looked up Nanna Bryndís Hilmarsdóttir last night, I read that she was born in 1989 and that her only solo album to date, the one that has "Disaster Master," is called How to Start a Garden.

The mention of swallows in the final paragraph of the novel proper reminded me of a sync I forgot to include in the post: Yesterday afternoon, after finding Commander Toad but before looking up Nanna, I read an article in an English textbook about how swifts look similar to swallows and can fly for as long as 10 months at a time without landing.

WanderingGondola said...

Last night I found myself browsing some threads in /vg/ (vidya generals). In the Cyberpunk 2077 thread there was some talk of a character named Songbird. I left off playing Cyberpunk months ago and was nowhere near the point where Songbird comes in, so I haven't read everything in the below link (although Google mostly wanted to show me stuff that, I assume, hints at the character's death).
cyberpunk.fandom.com/wiki/Song_So_Mi

Ra1119bee said...

William,
The song is the message from the language of the birds.
The message is wisdom and truth which is sweet like honey
because wisdom and truth sustains us.
The Song of Deborah. Davar meaning
the word.

Thoth's head of a Ibis is symbolic. Symbolizing
that Thoth knew the Language of the Birds,
the wise ones whose eyes can see far.

Isn't it interesting that recently Spirit Airlines ( airplanes
being connected with flight) just 'died'. Recall
I commented on your blog about May 6 or so
that I believe Spirit was sacrificed to be the Canary
in the coal mine for the upcoming
Great Reset ( Upheaval aka Shifting of Ages ).

Spirit Airlines colors are also
yellow and black, like a bee.

Keep in mind that wisdom and truth doesn't always
come from sweetness ( honey ) but from
the Darkness where honey is 'spun' in the hive.
The cave, like the hive is dark.

Recently something happened that got my immediate
attention.
Copy and paste: asterisks mine
"3 evacuated from hantavirus cruise ship as
Spain says it will dock in
***** Canary Islands**** despite local opposition".
~~~~~~~
I thought, hmmm... the birds again.
What's the odds???

Everything is connected.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hantavirus-canary-islands-cruise-ship-new-case-switzerland/

https://graceintorah.net/2014/04/16/deborah-the-bee/


Ra1119bee said...

William,
Oh, I forgot to add.
Toad could also be Told, as in 'to tell'.
Was William Tell a toad and a bow-ie?